Yet all this tells me is that the existence of a material world is immaterial, because it's purely a matter of belief ...Marquis de Carabas said:The material world either exists or it doesn't exist. And this [is] the absolute truth. So, what does this tell us about any supernatural notions we might have? That they are purely a matter of belief.
Of course, why bother to think at all?phildonnia said:Indeed.
Why should I bother to think about whether anything is true.
Placing my hand on a hot stove may burn my hand, or it may open the service entrance to the magical world of Narnia, but in any case, that is the absolute truth, whether I care to investigate it or not.
Studying geography on my part will not make one bit of difference in where the continents are actually placed, so what's the point? Investigating truth scientifically or not, it makes no difference to the actual laws of nature.
Yet all this tells me is that the existence of a supernatural world is unnatural, because it's purely a matter of belief ...Iacchus said:Yet all this tells me is that the existence of a material world is immaterial, because it's purely a matter of belief ...
Oh, and it clearly illustrates that absolute truth exists as well. Hmm ...
Iacchus said:The proof is all in your mind.
Prove it to a mind which doesn't exist ...Marquis de Carabas said:The proof is all in my whiskey...
Why bother to discuss it then?Piscivore said:Since "mind" doesn't exist either, there goes the "proof."![]()
That's the great thing about whiskey, Cap'n. The more proof you take in, the less real your mind gets.Iacchus said:Prove it to a mind which doesn't exist ...
Iacchus said:Prove it to a mind which doesn't exist ...
Iacchus said:Of course, why bother to think at all?
God either exists or He doesn't exist.
I won this debate - Argument by Liquor Ad.![]()
Iacchus said:God either exists or He doesn't exist. And this is the absolute truth. So, what does this tell us about any materialistic notions we might have? That they are purely a matter of belief.