I agree, and Andy would love the fact that he is still causing controversy.LFTKBS said:No, Zep, he was great, actually.
I find it amusing that Mr. Manifesto gets his digs on Kaufman despite never having seen his work.
Idiot.
American said:It could be metaphysical. Andy is alive in ALL OF US.
LFTKBS said:No, Zep, he was great, actually.
I find it amusing that Mr. Manifesto gets his digs on Kaufman despite never having seen his work.
Idiot.
Originally posted by Mr Manifesto, which he is forced to post again for the slower members of the politics forum
No, I don't hate him. Just his ever-growing legion of drooling fans. Would be quite interested to see some of his routines to see for myself what he was like.
Zep said:Sniping aside, I've spent an hour or so looking up some stuff about Andy Kaufman, and reading. Granted that's hardly anywhere near enough time to really learn to appreciate any performer, but my first impressions are that he was little more than a self-serving git whom some people thought was "a great comedian" solely because he acted weird.
So far, I'm not impressed, and losing interest rapidly...
Oh, har har! I never said it was "great", I just said it made me laugh!slimshady2357 said:
That's cool, that was the impression he gave a lot of people. Some people just don't 'get it'. And I'm hardly likely to agree with someone who thinks that Home Improvement was one of the great sitcoms![]()
But seriously, personally, there was some of his stuff I really liked, but there was lots of stuff I just didn't 'get'.
Someone above said he was 'love/hate' for fans, and it seems there was many 'hates', and quite a few 'loves'. I was somewhere in the middle, some of it I loved, certainly. In the end I think he was quite a bit of a 'self-serving git', but he was also someone that quite a few people thought was a great comedian.
Some people think Jackson Polack is just a wanker who threw paint onto canvas any old way. I hope they remember that other people thought he was a genius.
To each his own
Adam
LFTKBS said:No, Zep, he was great, actually.
I find it amusing that Mr. Manifesto gets his digs on Kaufman despite never having seen his work.
Idiot.
Zep said:Sniping aside, I've spent an hour or so looking up some stuff about Andy Kaufman, and reading. Granted that's hardly anywhere near enough time to really learn to appreciate any performer, but my first impressions are that he was little more than a self-serving git whom some people thought was "a great comedian" solely because he acted weird.
So far, I'm not impressed, and losing interest rapidly...
Mr Manifesto said:
Now subject to the usual blind hero-worship that some artists enjoy when they die.
Number Six said:I liked some of Andy Kaufman's comedy and I didn't like other parts of it. I think comedy should be judged on whether it's funny and not on whether it's different. I think a point came where some people like Kaufman's stuff simply because it was different and without regard to whether it was any good.
I didn't like the wrestling schtick. And I never even heard about the Tony Clifton stuff until long after he was dead.
I heard that he didn't like doing Taxi because he thought it was beneath him and too mainstream and all that, but it was funny and twenty years later it still is funny and as far as I'm concerned that's what count. I don't think some of his other stuff (especially his later stuff) has aged very well (but then again, I didn't like it that much when it first came out so perhaps that's why I like it even less now).
shanek said:The thing about Kaufman was, he wanted a genuine reaction. If you go into a comedy club, you're half expecting to laugh already, so in Kaufman's mind it's not so genuine since the audience is already meeting you halfway. So, what did Kaufman do? He played the part of a shy, not-very-funny-but-likeable stand-up comic. He blew his jokes, but was so sweet about it that the audience just fell in love with him. Then Zmuda (planted in the audience) started hecking him and became so much of an a**hole that he had Kaufman running off the stage in tears. The audience adored Kaufman, hated the heckler, and neither reaction was what the audience was prepared to have. So it was genuine. Love, hate, laughter, pity, whatever—Kaufman wanted to evoke sincere reactions that came from the heart. No performer before or since has ever come close.