kevsta
RBL CHeck Failed
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2007
- Messages
- 4,016
So a while back Stillicho took exception to my ridiculing of the Bernank's Fed for their terrible predictive record of the economy (that they made) and challenged me to prove that the Asset managers I follow are more accurate with their predictions and world views, and I accepted with conditions..
So lets start with a macro overview to set context. These are my beliefs along with the guys with whom I agree with their analysis.
We are following the timetable for what must come, so clearly laid out by Gordon T Long's extend & Pretend Roadmap back in Jan 2010 just after Dubai World defaulted (remember that far back?) as shown here, people were talking vaguely about Greece and Ireland as potential problems in the distant future at this point. (Gold dropped $70 in a day, nearly back to what I had recently paid for mine at that point)

as you can see things have moved along pretty much exactly to the roadmap since then, we are now well into the European sub-prime area in the diagram, with problems in eastern Europe - Hungary in crisis - with approx 60% of their mortgage debt denominated in Swiss CHF, the Euro peg and problems look set to seriously test the SNB's resolve and reserves, not to mention the Swiss and Austrian banks because Hungary have just passed a law that could definitely be classed as an attack in the currency wars to bail out their borrowers at the cost of foreign banks.
The European banking system is suffering institutional electronic-style bank runs out of Greece, Italy and Spain currently, with old style queuing-outside-the-door Bank runs in Latvia (pics)
Meridith's (and Gordon Long's more accurately timed) Muni / state calls will start coming in this year, Meridith is like Schiff in his US dollar predictions, early, but ultimately will be correct.
So in essence, I think 2012 will be the year that the wheels properly come off the central planners carts and everybody can finally see and accept:
That we (the global economy) are not recovering, and are not likely to before taking some real hardship.
That we are in fact now in year 4 of what will eventually be known as "The Greater Depression" - Schiff has been saying this for at least 18 months now, and even Krugman finally caught on a few weeks ago, this year the pretence will end for everyone else too.
That we are in a massive and unavoidable debt bubble collapse and de-leveraging, and an ongoing implosion of the western world shadow banking system, and trillions in debt writedowns of one form or another are the only real way out of it.
That housing is still overvalued in many places - http://www.economist.com/node/21540231
Europe will not hold together "as-is" - that which is not sustainable, will not be sustained. Greece & Portugal cannot remain in the current system as-is. There will be real defaults, as there is a €4-6 Trillion hole in the European balance sheet.
This will cross the Atlantic and infect the US banking system again via the Trillions of exposure in derivatives, making it absolutely clear to the US that they cannot and will not be "decoupling" from Europe's problems and growing their way out of anything just yet.
In a nutshell, it all has to get much worse, before it can even think about starting to recover.
China - the bubble bursting is now well underway - as predicted by Hugh Hendry back in 2009
Hendry is also poised right on the threshold of massive profits from bets taken two years ago that Europe was going back into recession, and will start seeing payment as soon as the ECB's interest rates go sub 1%, I think that is coming this year.
Here he is schooling Nobel Laureate Joseph Stiglitz on the real world economics and (as it turns out) some prophetic advice for the Spanish Finance minister.
Japan - this will be the year it all comes unraveled for Japan, as predicted by Kyle Bass, who this year has been paid handsomely from bets he was making on Greece defaulting in 2008/9, whilst the Bernank was trumpeting his "green shoots of recovery" nonsense.
Here's Kyle on BBC Hard Talk - this one is unmissable.
highlights include:
Australia - this is the year Australian housing finally catches up with gravity.
Steve Keen was also correct in his analysis of the AU property bubble, but was once again wrong footed on timing by central planners and stimulus interfering with market forces, but this cannot last forever, and with the China slowdown, whether (soft, or hard landing) so goes Aus in 2012.
Canada - same thing which will be the catalyst that exposes the much denied weaknesses in the Canadian banking system
UK - being from the UK originally I can comment in more depth on this one than most countries. In 2012 I think things will start to get really nasty in the UK, with approaching 1000% debt to GDP now
Consumer confidence at record lows as austerity finally starts to hit there (remember, for most homeowners, if you didn't lose your job in 08/09 things actually got much cheaper for you as mortgage interest rates plunged, most of "working home-owning UK" haven't felt much from the crisis yet) but now, with no doubt (in my mind anyway) about Britain plunging back into recession, and housing continuing it's inevitable downward trajectory, I would not be at all surprised to see the rioters back out properly, only this time they will know why they are rioting.
And for the wildcard, I'm going to go with a major energy shock this year, whether triggered by problems in the Middle East - Iran (which I have bet on via Intrade btw) or by Chris Martenson's analysis of exponential population and credit growth bumping up against finite EROEI with liquid fuels - IMO this lecture is the most important information I saw in 2011. (ignore the fact its at a Gold & silver conference, he doesn't mention either one once)
And so with all this debt collapse going on around the world, the one thing I think we can definitely rely on is the Central Planners kicking the printing into overdrive and doing everything in their power to try to prevent the tide coming in.
Whether they will succeed in preventing the inevitable once again, or whether they have finally run out of road this time I am not going to guess at, but I am pretty sure they'll try as hard as they can.
Jim Rickards thinks the US will start QE3 (although it wont be called that) in the form of "targeting NGDP" and they will give no figures and no dates or durations (no accountability) and that it will be triggered by the EURUSD reaching the mid 1.20s.
Zerohedge's (Bloomberg) ECB / Fed balance sheet seems like a reasonable guide to the EURUSD direction to me and also implies we should be nearer 1.20 than 1.30 currently.
so it does look likely to be heading downwards first, then up again when the Fed rev the printers up.
Given commodities (and virtually everything else - equities etc) strong correlation to EURUSD most of 2011, this would imply we are probably heading still lower in the first part of the year before the capitulation and printing begins in earnest.
Rickards also predicts a surprise in that not only will China not be letting its currency appreciate, they will be re-pegging and looking to devalue again in the next round of the ongoing Currency War. With the slowdown there and lowering of rates again, this also seems likely to me, to attempt to get back to some good old imported US inflation once more.
So given global printing like never before, some specific price predictions..
Gold - on the low side, if we go with the support/resistance levels of $1705 where it was before the negative lease rate shenanigins and end of year liquidations set in, and add just the average yearly gains this decade of 17% that gives us $1994.
On the high side if we go peak to peak from 2011's peak - $1910 and assume the same peak to peak rise as this year (34%) = $2550
so I predict we will see gold trade between $2000-$2500 in 2012.
Silver Silver's long term fundamentals are extremely strong, but it is such a tiny market, and so easily manipulated and held down by interests that hold more in shorts than many years mining could produce, it is more or less impossible to get accurate price discovery, but I will stand by a previous prediction here that we will see $75 in 2012.
Oil currently trading at $100 per barrel as a baseline, with potential energy shocks and massive printing, we have got to take out the previous $147 high, possibly as high as $200.
A few things from my contra indicators that I think wont be happening.
so there we go, gold, silver, oil, EURUSD and a whole lot more predictions besides. hopefully that's specific enough for you - lets face it I only have to get a single solitary one right to outperform Bernanke
lets see...
Happy New Year to all.
stilicho said:stilicho
Pick your favourite and we can watch wide-eyed as his or hers forecasts unfold before us. I supplied four really simple criteria but perhaps you have some others in mind. Let's hurry, though, because we can start this proposal of yours around New Years and follow your experts as they overshadow everyone in the business.
kevsta said:"my favourite" hmm, difficult to choose, there are a few. within this group there are alternate views and opinions on micro issues, but within the context of broadly similar macroviews
- Jim Rickards
- Eric Sprott
- Hugh Hendry
- Kyle Bass
- Reggie Middleton
- Steve Keen
- Gordon T Long
- Robin Griffiths
- Ben Davies
- Michael Pento
- Peter Schiff
- Jim Rogers
- Marc Faber
and so if I have until New Years I will accept your challenge, let me collate opinion across the guys who do have a clue, cross reference it with my Contra indicators
- Goldman sellside (Stolper, Jim O Neill etc)
- Whitney Tilson (see the anti Tilson ETF )
- Dennis Gartman
- Jim Cramer
- Bernanke
- Krugman
- Roubini
the problem we have with this though, is it is hugely dependent on what the FED actually do, ie Rickards thinks the Euro will survive and get stronger, and if the FED (IMF whatever) bail Europe out, he will likely be correct.
do you see how they (FED) might have a little inside knowledge with regards to these things and hence *should* be in a position to predict slightly better than outside observers?
So I think the predictions will be along the lines of:
"if they do this, then this.. but if they do this, then this.." is that acceptable?
So lets start with a macro overview to set context. These are my beliefs along with the guys with whom I agree with their analysis.
We are following the timetable for what must come, so clearly laid out by Gordon T Long's extend & Pretend Roadmap back in Jan 2010 just after Dubai World defaulted (remember that far back?) as shown here, people were talking vaguely about Greece and Ireland as potential problems in the distant future at this point. (Gold dropped $70 in a day, nearly back to what I had recently paid for mine at that point)

as you can see things have moved along pretty much exactly to the roadmap since then, we are now well into the European sub-prime area in the diagram, with problems in eastern Europe - Hungary in crisis - with approx 60% of their mortgage debt denominated in Swiss CHF, the Euro peg and problems look set to seriously test the SNB's resolve and reserves, not to mention the Swiss and Austrian banks because Hungary have just passed a law that could definitely be classed as an attack in the currency wars to bail out their borrowers at the cost of foreign banks.
The European banking system is suffering institutional electronic-style bank runs out of Greece, Italy and Spain currently, with old style queuing-outside-the-door Bank runs in Latvia (pics)
Meridith's (and Gordon Long's more accurately timed) Muni / state calls will start coming in this year, Meridith is like Schiff in his US dollar predictions, early, but ultimately will be correct.
So in essence, I think 2012 will be the year that the wheels properly come off the central planners carts and everybody can finally see and accept:
That we (the global economy) are not recovering, and are not likely to before taking some real hardship.
That we are in fact now in year 4 of what will eventually be known as "The Greater Depression" - Schiff has been saying this for at least 18 months now, and even Krugman finally caught on a few weeks ago, this year the pretence will end for everyone else too.
That we are in a massive and unavoidable debt bubble collapse and de-leveraging, and an ongoing implosion of the western world shadow banking system, and trillions in debt writedowns of one form or another are the only real way out of it.
That housing is still overvalued in many places - http://www.economist.com/node/21540231
Based on the average of the two measures, home prices are overvalued by about 25% or more in Australia, Belgium, Canada, France, New Zealand, Britain, the Netherlands, Spain and Sweden
Europe will not hold together "as-is" - that which is not sustainable, will not be sustained. Greece & Portugal cannot remain in the current system as-is. There will be real defaults, as there is a €4-6 Trillion hole in the European balance sheet.
This will cross the Atlantic and infect the US banking system again via the Trillions of exposure in derivatives, making it absolutely clear to the US that they cannot and will not be "decoupling" from Europe's problems and growing their way out of anything just yet.
In a nutshell, it all has to get much worse, before it can even think about starting to recover.
China - the bubble bursting is now well underway - as predicted by Hugh Hendry back in 2009
From the FT - Hugh Hendry, the outspoken UK hedge fund manager known for his bearish, often contrarian views on the global economy, has seen his ‘China short’ fund rack up gains of more than 52 per cent so far this year, investors have told the Financial Times.
Mr Hendry began raising concerns about a Chinese slowdown in 2009 – even uploading a homemade video on to the video sharing site YouTube based on a visit to deserted Chinese real estate developments.
Hendry is also poised right on the threshold of massive profits from bets taken two years ago that Europe was going back into recession, and will start seeing payment as soon as the ECB's interest rates go sub 1%, I think that is coming this year.
Here he is schooling Nobel Laureate Joseph Stiglitz on the real world economics and (as it turns out) some prophetic advice for the Spanish Finance minister.
Japan - this will be the year it all comes unraveled for Japan, as predicted by Kyle Bass, who this year has been paid handsomely from bets he was making on Greece defaulting in 2008/9, whilst the Bernank was trumpeting his "green shoots of recovery" nonsense.
Here's Kyle on BBC Hard Talk - this one is unmissable.
highlights include:
"debt has grown globally in the last 9 years from $80 trillion dollars to $210 trillion, so global credit market debt has grown at 13% per year for the last 9 years, where global GDP has grown at 4%"
"think about what you just asked me, basically what you're saying is if Germany goes joint and seperately liable with the profligate idiots in Southern europe, will that "solve" the scenario?
..how many of your family members and friends would you go joint and separately liable with?"
Australia - this is the year Australian housing finally catches up with gravity.
Steve Keen was also correct in his analysis of the AU property bubble, but was once again wrong footed on timing by central planners and stimulus interfering with market forces, but this cannot last forever, and with the China slowdown, whether (soft, or hard landing) so goes Aus in 2012.
Canada - same thing which will be the catalyst that exposes the much denied weaknesses in the Canadian banking system
UK - being from the UK originally I can comment in more depth on this one than most countries. In 2012 I think things will start to get really nasty in the UK, with approaching 1000% debt to GDP now
Consumer confidence at record lows as austerity finally starts to hit there (remember, for most homeowners, if you didn't lose your job in 08/09 things actually got much cheaper for you as mortgage interest rates plunged, most of "working home-owning UK" haven't felt much from the crisis yet) but now, with no doubt (in my mind anyway) about Britain plunging back into recession, and housing continuing it's inevitable downward trajectory, I would not be at all surprised to see the rioters back out properly, only this time they will know why they are rioting.
And for the wildcard, I'm going to go with a major energy shock this year, whether triggered by problems in the Middle East - Iran (which I have bet on via Intrade btw) or by Chris Martenson's analysis of exponential population and credit growth bumping up against finite EROEI with liquid fuels - IMO this lecture is the most important information I saw in 2011. (ignore the fact its at a Gold & silver conference, he doesn't mention either one once)
And so with all this debt collapse going on around the world, the one thing I think we can definitely rely on is the Central Planners kicking the printing into overdrive and doing everything in their power to try to prevent the tide coming in.
Whether they will succeed in preventing the inevitable once again, or whether they have finally run out of road this time I am not going to guess at, but I am pretty sure they'll try as hard as they can.
Jim Rickards thinks the US will start QE3 (although it wont be called that) in the form of "targeting NGDP" and they will give no figures and no dates or durations (no accountability) and that it will be triggered by the EURUSD reaching the mid 1.20s.
So it looks like we are going to get flooded with dollars. One other thing I would add to that, which I think is extremely bullish for the price of gold, I’ve been talking about QE3, but there is something even more insidious than that which we may see. It’s called NGDP targeting.
NGDP stands for Notional Gross Domestic Product. Targeting just means that the Fed is going to pick a target for growth in NGDP and then print as much as it takes to hit that target.
Now notional GDP is not the same as real GDP. In other words, notional GDP is real GDP plus inflation. If the Fed targets NGDP, what they are really saying is they don’t care about inflation anymore, they’ve given up. I’ve said all along the Fed wants inflation and this is a way of getting it. It’s also a way of destroying the debt by cheapening the dollar.
...Targeting notional GDP, it’s just a fancy way of saying printing or QE forever. I’m using the phrase QE3 to mean more printing, but I actually think what the Fed is going to do is target NGDP....
Zerohedge's (Bloomberg) ECB / Fed balance sheet seems like a reasonable guide to the EURUSD direction to me and also implies we should be nearer 1.20 than 1.30 currently.
so it does look likely to be heading downwards first, then up again when the Fed rev the printers up.
Given commodities (and virtually everything else - equities etc) strong correlation to EURUSD most of 2011, this would imply we are probably heading still lower in the first part of the year before the capitulation and printing begins in earnest.
Rickards also predicts a surprise in that not only will China not be letting its currency appreciate, they will be re-pegging and looking to devalue again in the next round of the ongoing Currency War. With the slowdown there and lowering of rates again, this also seems likely to me, to attempt to get back to some good old imported US inflation once more.
So given global printing like never before, some specific price predictions..
Gold - on the low side, if we go with the support/resistance levels of $1705 where it was before the negative lease rate shenanigins and end of year liquidations set in, and add just the average yearly gains this decade of 17% that gives us $1994.
On the high side if we go peak to peak from 2011's peak - $1910 and assume the same peak to peak rise as this year (34%) = $2550
so I predict we will see gold trade between $2000-$2500 in 2012.
Silver Silver's long term fundamentals are extremely strong, but it is such a tiny market, and so easily manipulated and held down by interests that hold more in shorts than many years mining could produce, it is more or less impossible to get accurate price discovery, but I will stand by a previous prediction here that we will see $75 in 2012.
Oil currently trading at $100 per barrel as a baseline, with potential energy shocks and massive printing, we have got to take out the previous $147 high, possibly as high as $200.
A few things from my contra indicators that I think wont be happening.
- Goldman's Jim O Neill's perennial "Equities up 20%" call
- Gartman / Roubini's Gold bubble bursting
so there we go, gold, silver, oil, EURUSD and a whole lot more predictions besides. hopefully that's specific enough for you - lets face it I only have to get a single solitary one right to outperform Bernanke
Disclaimer - I'm sure you can tell and that I don't need to say this, but I will anyway, I am not an investment advisor. Do not base any decisions on anything I have said here. You have not paid me for my advice therefore you do not have my permission to trade from it
I personally am heavily long physical gold and silver since 2009 and will be staying that way for the foreseeable future.
I will also be taking leveraged positions either short or long in gold, silver, oil, EURUSD and eMini Dow / S&P as opportunities present themselves, and so may have "money where mouth is" on some of these predictions from time to time.
Happy New Year to all.
Last edited:
