• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Urban Myth Website

Plastictowel

Thinker
Joined
Mar 14, 2006
Messages
226
Hey I saw a link to a website and lost it (it was on this forum)
Fobles.com? Something like that...debunks urban myths. Could someone please provide the link??? As I'm getting that dioxide cancer e-mail and want to send back to them proof it's a hoax.
 
Before I started to read this forum, and before a friend pointed me in the direction of Snopes (two totally unrelated events which happened more or less at the same time - OOOoOOOOOOhhh...), I must admit that I was guilty of both believing and perpetuating every single urban myth that dropped in my inbox. Even the Darwin awards.

Shame on me.
 
Before I started to read this forum, and before a friend pointed me in the direction of Snopes (two totally unrelated events which happened more or less at the same time - OOOoOOOOOOhhh...), I must admit that I was guilty of both believing and perpetuating every single urban myth that dropped in my inbox. Even the Darwin awards.

Shame on me.
My fiance, her mother and her friends were the same way. For a long time, I would simply reply to their forwards (sometimes I would even go a couple levels deep), with a link to the snopes article and a comment asking (not too nicely), if they could possibly find some evidence on stories before believing them. Fortunately, she always checks now.

There was an interesting one going around a couple months ago that a couple people I knew fell for. It stated that Mars would be closer to the earth than it had ever been in the past, apparently it would show up in the sky as large as the moon. This was a partially (although a small part) true about 3 years previous. Obviously it would not be that big (I could only imagine what the tidal forces would do to the Earth), and it gets that close every 17 years or so. They were all convinced in the email, even after I explained what the email really meant, that the event had already happened. I even explained eliptical orbits, apparent magnitudes of stellar objects, and tidal forces caused by massive objects.

Did they believe me? Nope. Pointed them to the Snopes article and they still didn't. All I got was the response "How do you know?" After the "event", they dropped it and never spoke of it again.

It is this kind of thing that really, really, REALLY bothers me. I can understand how one could believe in something really wacky but if the evidence against it is sitting right in front of you, how can you still believe? Why do people never take the time to look for even the smallest bit of evidence.

Take for example, the radio show I heard yesterday morning. They had a large number of questions that they asked the audience. One of them was the common "Which direction does water drain in your toilet in the northern hemisphere?" Every one of them answered that it turned either clockwise or counter clockwise and they said that it was based on the Coriolis effect. Obviously you should all know that the Coriolus effect has a insignificant effect on the flow of water down a drain, and only shows up when water has been sitting unmoving for 24 hours or more. It amazes me that none of these people had ever observed that the water actually drained both ways. In 25+ years of life, using a toilet, sink or tub at least once a day, none of these people had ever bothered to check if this common knowledge was true or not. Easily the most common urban legend of today. I hear it repeated all the time.

What is wrong with the world that they will accept such an easily disputed fact? I guess people are just lazy.
 
Snopes is pretty good but just remember, don't take everything snopes says as gospel. They have been known to be wrong on a few occasions and suffer from a tendency that all human beings have which is to interject their opinions into some topics.

Snopes isn't perfect but they do a pretty good job overall. Just remember to remain skeptical no matter what the source.
 
Snopes is pretty good but just remember, don't take everything snopes says as gospel. They have been known to be wrong on a few occasions and suffer from a tendency that all human beings have which is to interject their opinions into some topics.

Snopes isn't perfect but they do a pretty good job overall. Just remember to remain skeptical no matter what the source.

What's good about the snopes website is that they're comprehensive. They have buckets of urban myths recorded and analysed. Secondly, they're 99.9% right, which makes them reliable enough to be useful.

The caveat about opinion is true, but does not necessarily deduct from accuracy. I've only caught them once. The other 'needs improvement' issue is the graphics: they're from the school of powerpoint-clipart circa 1996.
 
Snopes is pretty good but just remember, don't take everything snopes says as gospel. They have been known to be wrong on a few occasions and suffer from a tendency that all human beings have which is to interject their opinions into some topics.

Snopes isn't perfect but they do a pretty good job overall. Just remember to remain skeptical no matter what the source.

I think the people at snopes would agree... they actually created a section of 'false' myths they claim as true (such as the animal that played Mr. Ed was actually a Zebra, not a horse), just to enourage people to be skeptical about everthing, even their own web site.

http://www.snopes.com/lost/lost.htm

http://www.snopes.com/lost/false.htm
 
Take for example, the radio show I heard yesterday morning. They had a large number of questions that they asked the audience. One of them was the common "Which direction does water drain in your toilet in the northern hemisphere?" Every one of them answered that it turned either clockwise or counter clockwise and they said that it was based on the Coriolis effect. Obviously you should all know that the Coriolus effect has a insignificant effect on the flow of water down a drain, and only shows up when water has been sitting unmoving for 24 hours or more. It amazes me that none of these people had ever observed that the water actually drained both ways. In 25+ years of life, using a toilet, sink or tub at least once a day, none of these people had ever bothered to check if this common knowledge was true or not. Easily the most common urban legend of today. I hear it repeated all the time.

What is wrong with the world that they will accept such an easily disputed fact? I guess people are just lazy.

Well, well, learn something new every day! I didn't know about this. I just assumed that it was true (yes, I am quite lazy!), and not just because it was the premise of a Simpson's episode either! On the other hand, it's not as though I based my entire belief system on it, and proceeded to live my life accordingly. Still very interesting, though. By the way, I did check that you were being sincere and not just testing gullibility levels!

http://www.ems.psu.edu/~fraser/Bad/BadCoriolis.html
 
I used to get a lot of those irritating emails and used to just delete them and go on, but then I started directing the senders to Snopes and as a result they rarely send me the stuff anymore, guess they'd rather not be told the truth, then they wouldn't have anything to "oooo" and "aaaaahhhh" over.
 
I used to get a lot of those irritating emails and used to just delete them and go on, but then I started directing the senders to Snopes and as a result they rarely send me the stuff anymore, guess they'd rather not be told the truth, then they wouldn't have anything to "oooo" and "aaaaahhhh" over.

The first myth email I get from someone gets a reply with the snopes (or other) article I found debunking it. ("You're wrong, but you might not have known. I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt.")

The second myth email I get from that person gets a reply with the google search terms I used to find the article debunking it. ("You're wrong again. You apparently need instruction.")

The third myth email I get from the same person gets the debunking article and the search terms and cc'd to everyone they sent it to. ("I'm calling you an idiot in public.")

They usually get the hint after three.
 
I used to hang out on their board a lot, it was fun looking at the new myths that came along.

That is, until I was banned for some unknown reason and all my e-mails went unanswered. Oh well, I guess you can thank (blame) them for my landing here :P
 
Are you male?

If so, you probably got banned for perceived sexism. That's what usually happens, as the board is dominated by a bunch of nagging, self-righteous, intolerant yentas. IMO, the snopes message boards is basically a chick party. Nothing wrong with that, but my experience was men and their opinions aren't needed or welcome. Of course, I'm generalizing, but generalizing based on my direct experience.

Can you tell I don't like the snopes message boards much?

But overall, snopes is a great resource. I just dislike the tone of the message boards.
 
Last edited:
I think the people at snopes would agree... they actually created a section of 'false' myths they claim as true (such as the animal that played Mr. Ed was actually a Zebra, not a horse), just to enourage people to be skeptical about everthing, even their own web site.

http://www.snopes.com/lost/lost.htm

http://www.snopes.com/lost/false.htm

Wasn't there a case where one of the big national news organizations (or was it the Discover channel or something) included one of those false Snopes articles in a story, as if it were true. I remember something like that happening, but can't remember details. Irritating.

Sorry for the tangent, but this is gnawing at my psyche now.
 
Sorry for the tangent, but this is gnawing at my psyche now.

I can get you a can of "Quantum Vibration Energy Natural Organic Magnetic Homeopathic Holistic Psyche Pest Repellent" for the low, low price of only $49.95!



plusshippingandhandlingandtaxeswhereapplicable
thesestatementshavenotbeenevaluatedbythefdathis
productisnotintendedtotreatdiagnoseorcureany
diseaseresultsnottypicalyourmileagemayvaryyou're
anabsolutesuckerifyoubuythisdidwejustsaythatout
loud
 

Back
Top Bottom