Fifty Thousand Bucks
New Blood
- Joined
- Oct 7, 2006
- Messages
- 14
Father Parmenides
Sir:
I'll be surprised if many people on this thread whether they style themselves materialists, idealists, closet idealists, or ... will wish to define materialism so.
I personally am unacquainted with any materialist who thinks that a statement of materialism is reducible to "whatever is is". Might you not be, perhaps faintly, recalling father Parmendides?
[[I almost forgot about Democritus et al - however, I'll be happy to assert and also back up the assertion that he isn't support for your statement either - outside this thread. But in any case, do you wish to also assert, "what is not is"? Be my guest.]]
Were our core concepts of "existence" so materially entwined, this thread wouldn't exist - apologies to RandFan, Still thinkin, et al.
Cheers,
FTB
Materialism is only the logical statement that everything that exists - exists (whether or not we currently know of or understand it). A denial of materialism is really a denial of logic.
If you (religious person of any persuasion) want your god to be real then you have to accept that he/she exists and is therefore bound by materialism.
Sir:
I'll be surprised if many people on this thread whether they style themselves materialists, idealists, closet idealists, or ... will wish to define materialism so.
I personally am unacquainted with any materialist who thinks that a statement of materialism is reducible to "whatever is is". Might you not be, perhaps faintly, recalling father Parmendides?
[[I almost forgot about Democritus et al - however, I'll be happy to assert and also back up the assertion that he isn't support for your statement either - outside this thread. But in any case, do you wish to also assert, "what is not is"? Be my guest.]]
Were our core concepts of "existence" so materially entwined, this thread wouldn't exist - apologies to RandFan, Still thinkin, et al.
Cheers,
FTB
.