• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Favourite mystery/detective novels

I like Lindsey Davies "Falco" series, Steven Saylor's "Gordianus the Finder" and David Wishart's "Marcus Corvinus" books (the last not influenced by the fact he taught me Latin at school for 2 years, honest!) I like most of the historical detectives but have a particular love of/fascination for Ancient Rome so these do it for me.
 
And then* read Raymond Chandler. Yes, he's an awful snob, and there's some toe-curling bigotry but there's such glee to be had from lines like "From 30 feet away she looked like a lot of class. From 10 feet away she looked like something made up to be seen from 30 feet away".

*Don't do it the other way round as Chandler's snappy dialogue makes Hammett's look rather dated (well of course they're both dated, but Chandler's pace and wit make Hammet sound like something from the previous century rather than the previous decade).

And of course you get to read it all with Humprey Bogart's voice in your head, which turns out to be one of life's great joys. :D

Yes! I've read all of Chandler and Hammet, many of them twice.

My favorite Chandler opening description of a man "who was as inconspicuous as a tarantula on a wedding cake."

But I have found some current jewels amongst crime writers:

David Baldacci
Jonathon Kellerman
Faye Kellerman
Patricia Cornwell
James Patterson
 
And of course you get to read it all with Humprey Bogart's voice in your head, which turns out to be one of life's great joys. :D

I listened to the audio book of The Maltese Falcon last week. The actor who read the Sam Spade part sounded black - a wonderful deep, resonant voice - but in my brain, he also sounded like ... Humphrey Bogart.

The actor who portrays Casper Gutman sounded JUST like Sydney Greenstreet though!
 
The First four of the Philo Vance novles are worth reading, after that the quality goes downhill fast.
And that Philo Vance comes off like an obnoxious jerk much of the time is not a plus. Ogden Nash said it right in his verse:

"Philo Vance Needs A Kick In The Pants".

Van Dyne was going for Lord Peter Whimsey type charecter and,IMHO, pretty much failed. Lord Peter was very likable and not at all a snob, Vance had none of those qualaties.
The first four novels are worth reading because of the clever plots,but after the plots go downhill the books become almost unreadable.
Yeah Wimsey inspired quite a bit of imitation, ranging from the good (Greenwood's Phryne Fisher is an excellent female Wimsey) to the mediocre (the later Vance as you mentioned). Rather like Holmes.

I'm reading the entire Lord Darcy series presently and there's a definite Wimsey/Bunter vibe there.
Excellent stories too, I wonder what Randi thought of his cameo as Chief Forensic Sorcerer of London?

Holmes, definitely Holmes. Conan Doyle mostly, but I've quite enjoyed the Anthony Horowitz House of Silk as well as several other pastiches.

I'm currently reading through Laurie King's Beekeeper series, and apart from the slight creepy old man vibe I get from it, I'm enjoying her take on the Holmes universe. Up to #9 in the series with three to go after it, I think.

Aside from that... well, I don't read mysteries all that much, so I can really only point to Jan Burke's series about a reporter named Irene Kelly, plus the rather cutesy but still fun series about a former reporter named Qwilleran with his two Siamese cats named Koko and Yum-Yum, where the character who invariably points Qwilleran in the right direction is his apparently hyper-intelligent cat Koko; I think the series is called "The Cat Who...", but I can't recall the author.

I did grow up on the original Nancy Drew stories; despite their being terribly formulaic and generic in their approach, I still enjoy reading them out of nostalgia, if nothing else. But my taste in literature tends more toward romance and sci-fi/fantasy than it does mysteries.
Lilian Jackson Braun wrote The Cat Who series; I liked them despite the efforts she went to pad out the quite short stories.
I've read a couple of Irene Kelly' books, I like them but she started using the superman serial killer meme a little much.

If you like SF/F you might like the Lord Darcy stories; basically a blend of Wimsey and Holmes in an alternate world with Victorian technology and scientific magic.
And a sorcerer never does it. :)
 
Yeah Wimsey inspired quite a bit of imitation, ranging from the good (Greenwood's Phryne Fisher is an excellent female Wimsey) to the mediocre (the later Vance as you mentioned). Rather like Holmes.

I'm reading the entire Lord Darcy series presently and there's a definite Wimsey/Bunter vibe there.
Excellent stories too, I wonder what Randi thought of his cameo as Chief Forensic Sorcerer of London?


Lilian Jackson Braun wrote The Cat Who series; I liked them despite the efforts she went to pad out the quite short stories.
I've read a couple of Irene Kelly' books, I like them but she started using the superman serial killer meme a little much.

If you like SF/F you might like the Lord Darcy stories; basically a blend of Wimsey and Holmes in an alternate world with Victorian technology and scientific magic.
And a sorcerer never does it. :)

Thanks, I'll look that up! Do you know the author, by chance?

There's also a series I forgot to mention, set in a sort of steampunk/sorcerous version of London written by Lilith Saintcrow. One of the characters is supposedly based somewhat off of Holmes; he's a "mentath" (which is basically described as a sort of talent that makes the person in question dryly logical and extremely methodical in their doings, which makes them ideal investigators; the downside is, if the talent isn't used, the brain literally turns on itself) named Clare, who teams up with a sorceress named Emma Bannon to investigate various mysteries. There've only been two in the series so far, but I've enjoyed both immensely.
 
Yeah Wimsey inspired quite a bit of imitation, ranging from the good (Greenwood's Phryne Fisher is an excellent female Wimsey) to the mediocre (the later Vance as you mentioned). Rather like Holmes.

I'm reading the entire Lord Darcy series presently and there's a definite Wimsey/Bunter vibe there.
I keep hearing about the Phryne Fisher series -- never encountered directly, must seek out -- just, please don't let the heroine hook up with a ruined WW1 veteran ! -- I'd have no quarrel with that happening in real life, and good luck to both of them -- just, please let whodunnits mostly be whodunnits, without greatly-distracting sub-plots ! (As said, I know nothing about the series -- for all I know, Phryne is lesbian / asexual / voluntarily celibate for whatever reason...)
 
I've been doing a fair amount of travelling recently and reading a lot of ebooks. I've read and re-read a lot of stuff, mysteries, scifi and fantasy along with non-fiction and a lot of althist.
So, as there don't seem to be any threads devoted to favourite and recommended mysteries I decided to start one.

I only mention it because you also mention scifi/fantasy, but I found most of the Dresden Files books great fun. Kind of "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" meets Dashiel Hammett. They are relatively short, and don't require a great deal of concentration, so they are great for airports, planes, etc..
 
Phillip Kerr's Bernie Gunther series.
Gunther starts out as a cop in pre-war Germany; the books take him all the way from there, through the war and into the post-war period. There's a heck of a lot of historical detail and Kerr inserts real incidents and people into the stories; Gunther gets to meet several Nazi war criminals and other high-ups, and is forced into fighting the Russians, for instance.If you want to read about WWII in Europe, it's all there - along with good crime plots.
 
for all I know, Phryne is lesbian / asexual / voluntarily celibate for whatever reason...)
oh no, not Phryne. :D She won't disappoint as the hero.

I haven't actually read any of the books. I've listened to them as audiobooks. I borrowed the first one (we can borrow digital audiobooks from our library, downloading them online) and really liked the reader, so I kept on with the series (and some titles from another author read by the same woman).

The titles are very easily "digestible", really good to listen to in the car. No involved sub-plots, very easy to put down and pick up again.
 
Thanks, I'll look that up! Do you know the author, by chance?
Oops, I should have included that; Randall Garrett wrote the original stories (and one novel) they were collected by Baen in one volume a few years ago.
Michael Kurland (an excellent author, try his 'Moriarty' books) wrote two further novels; Ten Little Wizards and A Study in Sorcery

There's also a series I forgot to mention, set in a sort of steampunk/sorcerous version of London written by Lilith Saintcrow. One of the characters is supposedly based somewhat off of Holmes; he's a "mentath" (which is basically described as a sort of talent that makes the person in question dryly logical and extremely methodical in their doings, which makes them ideal investigators; the downside is, if the talent isn't used, the brain literally turns on itself) named Clare, who teams up with a sorceress named Emma Bannon to investigate various mysteries. There've only been two in the series so far, but I've enjoyed both immensely.
I'd heard of these but never tried them, I'll add them to my list. Thanks.

I keep hearing about the Phryne Fisher series -- never encountered directly, must seek out -- just, please don't let the heroine hook up with a ruined WW1 veteran ! -- I'd have no quarrel with that happening in real life, and good luck to both of them -- just, please let whodunnits mostly be whodunnits, without greatly-distracting sub-plots ! (As said, I know nothing about the series -- for all I know, Phryne is lesbian / asexual / voluntarily celibate for whatever reason...)
:D No, Phryne is definitely not asexual, lesbian or celibate. And while she does hook up with a damaged WW1 veteran it's a brief fling.
There are a number of sub-plots, some ongoing from book to book, so it's a good idea to read them in order. I've seen them on the shelves of my main bookstore in Dublin so I assume they've a UK publisher now, I used to have to order them from Allen and Unwin.
 
so I assume they've a UK publisher now, I used to have to order them from Allen and Unwin.
If anyone's interested in the audiobooks, the mob who publishes those is called Bolinda Audio. They sell titles as well as supply the ones we can borrow through the library. It's online, so it may be available to OS customers as well as us.
 
:D No, Phryne is definitely not asexual, lesbian or celibate. And while she does hook up with a damaged WW1 veteran it's a brief fling.
There are a number of sub-plots, some ongoing from book to book, so it's a good idea to read them in order. I've seen them on the shelves of my main bookstore in Dublin so I assume they've a UK publisher now, I used to have to order them from Allen and Unwin.
Thanks. I'm fascinated by the period -- really must try the Phryne Fisher books.
 
Oops, I should have included that; Randall Garrett wrote the original stories (and one novel) they were collected by Baen in one volume a few years ago.
Michael Kurland (an excellent author, try his 'Moriarty' books) wrote two further novels; Ten Little Wizards and A Study in Sorcery


I'd heard of these but never tried them, I'll add them to my list. Thanks.


:D No, Phryne is definitely not asexual, lesbian or celibate. And while she does hook up with a damaged WW1 veteran it's a brief fling.
There are a number of sub-plots, some ongoing from book to book, so it's a good idea to read them in order. I've seen them on the shelves of my main bookstore in Dublin so I assume they've a UK publisher now, I used to have to order them from Allen and Unwin.

Thank you, and you're welcome for the suggestion as well.

The two books are called "The Iron Wyrm Affair" and "The Red Plague Affair", if you need help finding them.
 
In the realm of Science Fiction Detective novels , Isaac Asimov set the standard with "Caves of Steel" and "The Naked Sun" .

And surprised no one has mentiones Elizabeth Peters Amelia Peabody novels. If Amelia were still alive, Egypt would not be in the mess it is in.......
 
In the realm of Science Fiction Detective novels , Isaac Asimov set the standard with "Caves of Steel" and "The Naked Sun" .

And surprised no one has mentiones Elizabeth Peters Amelia Peabody novels. If Amelia were still alive, Egypt would not be in the mess it is in.......

It wouldn't dare!
 

Back
Top Bottom