There are several comics-related threads I'd like to start over time, so before beginning this one I'd like to list some others and describe what each is (and isn't) intended to cover.
1. Comics for Skeptics.
2. Comics of Possible Interest to Skeptics.
3. Great Moments In Great Literature.
The first, Comics for Skeptics, would be intended as a place to mention, describe, and discuss comics people think skeptics would enjoy and might want to buy for themselves, or give as gifts, or see about placing in libraries. This would include comics that present skeptics in a positive light, that deal skeptically with paranormal issues such as faith-healing or speaking with the dead, etc.
Since many, many comics take super-science (people who come from other planets with higher gravity than earth will be able to fly; swallowing a pill can make a person shrink down to microscopic size, and swallowing another can restore the person to full-size; etc.) or the supernatural (ghosts, curses, and gods are real), it could be a valuable educational resource for skeptics to know which comics, especially which ones currently available, do not pander to these beliefs.
Examples of comics that might be mentioned in this thread are Jim Ottaviani's Two-Fisted Science and Dignifying Science (trade paperbacks that present stories about real-life scientists), Sandwalk Adventures (which satirizes religion and presents an enjoyable and understandable explanation of the theory of evolution), and individual issues of comics in which questions about the paranormal or supernatural are raised and then dealt with in a praise-worthy manner. (I already put up a post about Sandwalk Adventures, since I didn't want to wait until I had time to start this larger thread, but there are numerous other comics deserving mention.)
Largely this thread would be a heads-up to alert people to such comics; a typical post would supply information such as title, publisher, price, how to find or order copies, and a little description of what the comic is about and why it's worth knowing about. Sometimes another poster might care to add additional information about a title (such as to second a recommendation, give some background on the comic or its publisher, point out short-comings to a recommended title, discuss some of the contents, whatever.)
The second, Comics of Possible Interest to Skeptics, would be more concerned with currently-availble comics and would be for discussing bad as well as good examples. One reason for a thread like this is that it would enable skeptics to write letters to the editor (or, as comic book letter columns increasingly are phased out, to web-sites and bulletin boards) commenting on these issues and suggesting resources comics writers (and readers) might enjoy looking up.
For instance, there was a Daredevil story many years ago in which Uri Geller guest-starred, using psychic powers to bend steel bars and help defeat super-criminals. Some readers wrote in to explain how Geller worked many of his tricks and to recommend Randi's book, The Magic of Uri Geller.
This would be more of a discussion thread than the previous one. A typical post might be someone writing in to give thoughts about the religious views presented in the current incarnation of Spectre, or to ask for people's thoughts about 21 Down (imagine John Edwards as a young punk tattoo artist, except as an unconventional super-hero rather than a TV scam artist), or about God's guest-starring role (as a baseball-bat-carrying young boy) in Supergirl.
The third, Great Moments in Great Literature, might need to be retitled a little, just in case there are people who don't automatically think comics when great literature is mentioned. The idea with this would be for people not simply to say things like"Action Girl is my favorite comic!" or "Castle Waiting rocks!" but to describe some particular bit from the comic that the poster especially liked. A typical post might include a brief summary of some plot twist [marked with spoiler warning, so as not to spoil it for people who don't want it given away], or quote some favorite passage, or describe a favorite character and what makes her or him so memorable.
Besides giving people reading the posts a bit more to go on in deciding whether to check something out, this could also be a lot of fun, both in getting to tell favorite moments one recalls and getting to read other people's favorite bits.
So that leaves # 4, Current Comics Worth A Look, the thread I'm actually starting. This is more general than Comics For Skeptics, since the comic doesn't need to relate to skeptical issues. It just needs to be a comic book, current, and something that the poster thinks is good enough to be worth other people's attention. Discussion might come up about older comics (such as previous comics the creators worked on, or comics one is reminded of) or about the stories in the comics mentioned, or about thing in the real world that relate to the comics mentioned, but the main focus would be good current comics.
I get a box or so of comics each month. I'm just now going through the one that arrived in early October while I was away picking apples, so some of the comics I'm about to recommend have already been out more than a month. A new box should arrive in a few days, so if I'm eager to post about a few of these while they can still be called current.
Since I tend to write at length once I get started, my intention is to cover only one title per post. (This has nothing to do with trying to rack up a higher post count; I've already passed the 200 mark and so am qualified to have an an avatar and to receive the secret information packet that we're not supposed to tell newbies about.)
1. Comics for Skeptics.
2. Comics of Possible Interest to Skeptics.
3. Great Moments In Great Literature.
The first, Comics for Skeptics, would be intended as a place to mention, describe, and discuss comics people think skeptics would enjoy and might want to buy for themselves, or give as gifts, or see about placing in libraries. This would include comics that present skeptics in a positive light, that deal skeptically with paranormal issues such as faith-healing or speaking with the dead, etc.
Since many, many comics take super-science (people who come from other planets with higher gravity than earth will be able to fly; swallowing a pill can make a person shrink down to microscopic size, and swallowing another can restore the person to full-size; etc.) or the supernatural (ghosts, curses, and gods are real), it could be a valuable educational resource for skeptics to know which comics, especially which ones currently available, do not pander to these beliefs.
Examples of comics that might be mentioned in this thread are Jim Ottaviani's Two-Fisted Science and Dignifying Science (trade paperbacks that present stories about real-life scientists), Sandwalk Adventures (which satirizes religion and presents an enjoyable and understandable explanation of the theory of evolution), and individual issues of comics in which questions about the paranormal or supernatural are raised and then dealt with in a praise-worthy manner. (I already put up a post about Sandwalk Adventures, since I didn't want to wait until I had time to start this larger thread, but there are numerous other comics deserving mention.)
Largely this thread would be a heads-up to alert people to such comics; a typical post would supply information such as title, publisher, price, how to find or order copies, and a little description of what the comic is about and why it's worth knowing about. Sometimes another poster might care to add additional information about a title (such as to second a recommendation, give some background on the comic or its publisher, point out short-comings to a recommended title, discuss some of the contents, whatever.)
The second, Comics of Possible Interest to Skeptics, would be more concerned with currently-availble comics and would be for discussing bad as well as good examples. One reason for a thread like this is that it would enable skeptics to write letters to the editor (or, as comic book letter columns increasingly are phased out, to web-sites and bulletin boards) commenting on these issues and suggesting resources comics writers (and readers) might enjoy looking up.
For instance, there was a Daredevil story many years ago in which Uri Geller guest-starred, using psychic powers to bend steel bars and help defeat super-criminals. Some readers wrote in to explain how Geller worked many of his tricks and to recommend Randi's book, The Magic of Uri Geller.
This would be more of a discussion thread than the previous one. A typical post might be someone writing in to give thoughts about the religious views presented in the current incarnation of Spectre, or to ask for people's thoughts about 21 Down (imagine John Edwards as a young punk tattoo artist, except as an unconventional super-hero rather than a TV scam artist), or about God's guest-starring role (as a baseball-bat-carrying young boy) in Supergirl.
The third, Great Moments in Great Literature, might need to be retitled a little, just in case there are people who don't automatically think comics when great literature is mentioned. The idea with this would be for people not simply to say things like"Action Girl is my favorite comic!" or "Castle Waiting rocks!" but to describe some particular bit from the comic that the poster especially liked. A typical post might include a brief summary of some plot twist [marked with spoiler warning, so as not to spoil it for people who don't want it given away], or quote some favorite passage, or describe a favorite character and what makes her or him so memorable.
Besides giving people reading the posts a bit more to go on in deciding whether to check something out, this could also be a lot of fun, both in getting to tell favorite moments one recalls and getting to read other people's favorite bits.
So that leaves # 4, Current Comics Worth A Look, the thread I'm actually starting. This is more general than Comics For Skeptics, since the comic doesn't need to relate to skeptical issues. It just needs to be a comic book, current, and something that the poster thinks is good enough to be worth other people's attention. Discussion might come up about older comics (such as previous comics the creators worked on, or comics one is reminded of) or about the stories in the comics mentioned, or about thing in the real world that relate to the comics mentioned, but the main focus would be good current comics.
I get a box or so of comics each month. I'm just now going through the one that arrived in early October while I was away picking apples, so some of the comics I'm about to recommend have already been out more than a month. A new box should arrive in a few days, so if I'm eager to post about a few of these while they can still be called current.
Since I tend to write at length once I get started, my intention is to cover only one title per post. (This has nothing to do with trying to rack up a higher post count; I've already passed the 200 mark and so am qualified to have an an avatar and to receive the secret information packet that we're not supposed to tell newbies about.)