• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Black Cats

the confusion about black cats being unlucky or luck stems from the fact that in UK it is lucky when one crosses your path and in the USA it is unlucky.

I think.

Feel free to tell me I'm wrong.

Supersition wise, correct (I guess, not familiar with black cat UK lore). Cat owner/provider of kibble/litter box scooper wise I'm guessing no.

Scarlett might disagree since Hattie had a rough kittenhood and imposed her will on the former more than I might have liked, but my life took a definate turn for the better after she crossed my path and did so even to the point of me tripping over her (and Scarlett depending on the situation).

But then again I'm a skeptic cat afficianado, so who am I to comment on cat related superstitions. :)
 
That's as good a way as any of describing it. The fact is that because probability is random, luck exists - we have times when strings of things go well and others when strings of things go wrong.

Probability says that someone will win the New Jersey Pick 6 once in four drawings. That it will happen to any one particular person is about one in 14 million. The guy it does happen to "got lucky" even though it was bound to happen to someone.

In any series of random events, it will be possible to find a string of outcomes that seems to defy probability taken on its own. If it is a string of favorable outcomes, it is perceived as "lucky". If it is a string of unfavorable outcomes, it is perceived as "unlucky". In the long run, they tend to balance out.

I have a friend who is very lucky. She always seems to win things. One time on a ski trip, we walked into a bar and the waitress handed us each a raffle ticket saying they were having a free drawing for a pair of skis. She won them. She once won $4000 in a slot machine in Atlantic City. She won a new laptop from some other drawing. She's always winning something. Does this mean anything beyond what can be explained by probability? No. She wins a lot of stuff because she is always entering drawings. I only hear about the ones she did win. But even if her winning streak is above what probability would dictate for the number of contests she enters, the fact is that random events are not uniformly distributed. Because of that, there are bound to be some people who win more often than others.

Get fifty thousand people to flip a coin a hundred times and the average of heads-up occurrences is going to be very close to 50%. For each person though, some are going to have a higher occurrence of heads than others. Some may be very high. For instance, tossing 70 or more heads out of a hundred flips will happen about once in 25,000 attempts, which means it's going to happen to two people, on average, in our example. If a head is seen as a favorable outcome (maybe they get a dollar for each head they throw and lose a dollar for each tail), these people will be seen as "lucky". But probability says it will happen to someone. Luck is when it happens to me.

Combine the confirmation bias with the fact that some people will win more often than others by sheer probability, and my friend's uncanny luck is explained. No black cats necessary.
 
Combine the confirmation bias with the fact that some people will win more often than others by sheer probability, and my friend's uncanny luck is explained.

You've covered it all nicely, but that's all just a prosaic description of what luck actually is. It's like describing a rainbow as "white light refracted through water into its component colours" then claiming there are no rainbows.
 
You've covered it all nicely, but that's all just a prosaic description of what luck actually is. It's like describing a rainbow as "white light refracted through water into its component colours" then claiming there are no rainbows.

I'm not claiming there is no such thing as luck. I'm merely attempting to give a practical definition of luck that fits reality. "Luck" as a force that can be manipulated, changed, or influenced by the application of rites or charms does not exist. "Luck" as a personalized perception of probability does. As is usually the case, it depends on what you mean by "luck" whether or not it exists. It's like arguing about whether or not mirages are real when one person is talking about the illusion of water and the other about the water.
 
The only effect I can think of that having on my luck was when I tripped over her after I'd been drinking.



Generally speaking, when I trip over cat*, it's bad luck for the cat.








*Now, when I tip over a cat, that's just hilarious!
 
I always thought the superstition was that if a black cat crossed your path, it meant you were already screwed.

Well, not really. It is just that the light reflected from black cat fur undergoes a n-dimensional polarisation which makes it affect the local probability matrix.

Unfortunately most possible but improbable events that could result from this aren't good for you. Therefore black cats are mostly an unlucky sign and they are much less dangerous in the dark. :D

Edit: I forgot to add: For some reason the effect can not be reproduced under laboratory conditions.
 
Last edited:
I feed a feral black cat. This beautiful cat won't let me touch him but when I set the cat food out he eats his fill. I wish I could take him to the vet but I'm sure if I touched him he'd claw me to ribbons.
 

Back
Top Bottom