Whither Afghanistan?

Bikewer

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Sep 12, 2003
Messages
13,242
Location
St. Louis, Mo.
After some eight years of involvement, we seem to have accomplished little in our adventuring in Afghanistan, and you will be hard pressed to find a pundit of any stripe with much positive to say about the situation there.
In fact, all the various authorities I've listened to lately seem to have nothing much but gloom and doom to report.
There are far too few troops present to accomplish the security of the place, and apparently little interest on the part of the NATO types to supply more.
The Taliban have a safe haven in neighboring Pakistan, despite recent efforts by the Pakistani military to suppress them.
Corruption appears to be the order of the day, the central government is essentially powerless, and the economy, such as it is, is fueled by the drug trade.

Obama campaigned on the basis that Afghanistan is "the war we should have fought", but arguably that war is over and now it's something different entirely.

Various powers have come to grief in the place, and it doesn't appear we're doing much better.
At what point do we call the thing off, or should we make the large and difficult-to-swallow idea of large-scale nation building with all that would entail?
 
There is a lot at stake in Afghanistan. If we don't fix the problem there, we could regret it later. We must make sure they get a central government that is strong enough to keep the Taliban in line.
 
Michael Yon just finished a stint embedded with British troops in Afghanistan, his is by far the best reporting I've seen from the place. His blog is an excellent read: http://www.michaelyon-online.com/

I was always of the mind that sending more troops to Afghanistan may be counter-productive and simply give the Taliban more targets without doing much for the security of the country. I hope I was wrong, but things aren't looking great there currently.
 

Back
Top Bottom