I have a very good friend to whom I revealed my weak atheism a few weeks ago (that damn rule about no prepositions makes awkward sentences...). She asked me (as was pointed out eerily in another recent thread) how should she "pray" for me, or express her generic support? I am personally not offended by being told people are praying for me... a little amused, as if someone were going to clip their toenails (or something equally useless) for my problems, so it was a non-isue for me. She pressed on, wanting to ingratiate: being a pantheist, she believes all religions have some truth (oddly enough even athiesm, she goes all the way with pantheism), and tries to speak to each religiously as they require. Here was my response to her, and I would like to submit it to the group... you may find it useful...
Now, the really interesting part of this is... how does this differ from just making a generic comforting statement that can apply to anyone? In no way. In including all, we don't even have to account for all these other religions and offending them. Instead of trying to cater to every one's religion, while a nice thought (and probably leads to her greater understanding of religion), just make the most innocuous statements.
<Edited for more descriptive title>
<name removed>,
I seem to find that mostly prayers expresses the wishes and hopes of the supplicant. I guess I would say "I hope that reality is manipulated to your advantage" or some such, but that is too verbose and silly. I don't think hopes or wishes or luck really helps, either. The only point I feel that prayer has for the person being prayed for is just the sense that someone cares about them, and is concerned for their well-being: i.e. empathy. Therefore, I guess my "prayer" for atheism would be:
"I really know how you feel and understand. I will keep you in my thoughts, and if you need anything, let me know. If I can think of a way to help you, I will certainly do my best."
Now, the really interesting part of this is... how does this differ from just making a generic comforting statement that can apply to anyone? In no way. In including all, we don't even have to account for all these other religions and offending them. Instead of trying to cater to every one's religion, while a nice thought (and probably leads to her greater understanding of religion), just make the most innocuous statements.
<Edited for more descriptive title>