• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Sauna Therapy

kk2796

Student
Joined
Jul 23, 2004
Messages
44
Anyone with some medical/physiological knowledge want to poke some holes in this one? My wife's aunt and uncle have purchased an infrared sauna for their basement (cool enough concept - use focused infrared to heat the body rather than just "hot air" of a typical sauna, allowing you to heat the body tissue in a 125 degree (F) room instead of 180+ degrees, which makes the sauna experience much more enjoyable).

My problem is with the (what seems to me and my wife to be) underlying quackery. Here's several questionable claims made during the tour:
1) Human fat tissue is a dumping ground for "toxins", e.g. mercury.
2) "Toxins" are a major culprit for cancers and other ailments in our society.
3) When the fat tissue is heated in the sauna, it reaches temps of 100 - 105 degrees F, and becomes water soluble.
4) Somehow, because the fat is water soluble, and the body is sweating profusely, the assumption is that the body is "flushing" the toxins out of the body at a rapid rate.
5) It is suggested that a shower be taken immediately afterward to rinse the flushed toxins off the body before reabsorbption can occur.
6) Anecdotal point was made that some dentist of 35 years somewhere "had mercury levels of over 300 units, compared to an average of 5 - 8 units in the rest of the population, but after a month of sauna / thermal treatment, had levels plummet all the way down to 3 units". No names/citations were used... I'm basically curious if this is even coherent, much less based on a known incident.

Edit for clarity: 7) Don't eat the fatty part along the spinal ridge of fish... because that's where the toxins are.

Edit - forgot one: 8) The average adult has over 1200 toxins in their body... analysis of placental blood shows upwards of 300 toxins already in a newborn baby.
Thanks in advance!
 
Last edited:
Considering that I grew up with a traditional hot-air sauna, I'd say that it definately cleans you up. Maybe not the insides, but definately the outside.

I do think that a sauna provides a psychological escape from the coldness of winter. Even if you are outside in the cold. Just looking forward to the hot room and a cold beer makes you all warm inside.
 
I think you could substitute "by products" for most of their unlisted "toxins".

While the body does sequester heavy metals into fat and hair, that is the way the body takes it out of circulation. The mentioned dentist's (serum?)mercury level probably would have dropped without the woo IR sauna.

I'd be more concerned with electrolyte depletion before I'd expect any measurable 'de-toxifying' of any actual toxin.

Wood fires give off lots of energy in the IR range already. The only improvement in this is the electricity- saves hauling logs, ventilation, etc. I think you could have the same benefits a lot cheaper by closing the bathroom door and turning on the red-hot-wire heating element- which is nickle and chromium alloy....probaly putting heavy metal iions into the air.

Note: at least, this is what the voices told me to tell you. But they do sound lots weaker in the sauna, it must be the Quantum energy from the IR waves interfering with the sound waves within my head...

CAUTION- Infra Red heat will cause your tin foil hat to get very HOT. Not to mention that the sweat caused by the sauna will short circuit the tin....foiling it's benefits...
 
I dunno, I find sitting around naked in a steamy wooden shed to be very theraputic and good for me...





...as long as there's naked skepchicks with me.
 
Anyone with some medical/physiological knowledge want to poke some holes in this one?

98% crap.

The non-crap: The sweat glands are part of the excretory system. They do excrete waste products. Probably not as much as you pee when you drink extra water from being in the sauna, though. It's good for your skin, and it can clear out your sinuses.

The rest is crap.

Toxins: big load of crap. It's a perfectly ordinary word, meaning something that is toxic. But in so-called alternative medicine, it's a code word for a real woo concept.

Your body is an engine, or a bunch of engines, amongst other things. Stuff goes in (desirable, stuff, hopefully), and stuff goes out. Yeah, you want to get rid of the stuff that goes out. That's why there are toilets. But there's no special toxin thingie that's just going to come to the surface if you're in the sauna but won't get excreted in due time otherwise.

1200 numbered toxins? Big, steaming, succulent, malleable, stinking pile of crap. Just the number of different proteins you excrete is way bigger than 1200. And newborn babies have some stuff in them? No surprise. Fetuses even drink their own pee in the uterus.
 
An easy experiment for number 3....
Get a nice belly of pork* and slow roast it, eat it but save the fat and let it cool. Heat a pan of water to 100-105 F. Try and dissolve the fat in the water, if you try hard enough (screw top jar is good) you may get an emulsion briefly but it will be unstable

* Pork flesh is, as far as I know, similar enough to human flesh (Insulin, cloned flesh, heart valves) that it is a suitable analogue for this.
 

Back
Top Bottom