Pull it - Recut! Silverstein explains his comment...

Oliver

Penultimate Amazing
Oliver
Joined
Aug 12, 2006
Messages
17,396
Just saw this link at 911Podcasts.com:

http://www.911podcasts.com said:
America Rebuilds 2
Larry Silverstein goes back on TV to explain why building 7 was pulled.
Click to expand...

And Dustin Hoffman is in "MIHOP" mode?

http://911blogger.com/ said:
Dustin Hoffman Says Bush Has Manipulated 9/11

Acclaimed screen star DUSTIN HOFFMAN has slammed US President
GEORGE W BUSH for manipulating the 9/11 terrorist attacks to facilitate
the invasion and occupation of Iraq.

The RAIN MAN actor now feels "self-conscious" about being American
because he can understand why the nation has become a focus for
resentment around the world.

He says, "I think that the administration manipulated the grief of 9/11.
They did it then and they do it now.

"Everybody knows why they wanted to go into Iraq and it had nothing
to do with weapons of mass destruction. I'm an American and it's not
a good feeling. When Americans say, 'I don't know why they hate us so
much,' that's an uneducated response. There are lots of reasons why
we're hated."
Click to expand...
 
Last edited:
From that quote, I don't think Dustin Hoffman is saying MIHOP. He's saying that post-9/11, Bush manipulated the grief of Americans to justify invading Iraq. Which he did and continues to do.
 
Lisa Simpson said:
From that quote, I don't think Dustin Hoffman is saying MIHOP. He's saying that post-9/11, Bush manipulated the grief of Americans to justify invading Iraq. Which he did and continues to do.
Click to expand...

I may translated the post at 911Blogger the wrong way
after reading the header. Did someone find the original
source where he said it?

@Lisa: Thank you for moving the thread to the right place. :)

Dustin Hoffman Says Bush Has Manipulated 9/11

Acclaimed screen star DUSTIN HOFFMAN has slammed US President GEORGE W BUSH for manipulating the 9/11 terrorist attacks to facilitate the invasion and occupation of Iraq.
Click to expand...
 
Word subtraction!

Headline: Hoffman says Bush manipulated 9/11

Text of article: Hoffman says Bush manipulated grief of 9/11

Bolding mine.

BIIIIIIIIIIG difference there. Headline says Hoffman thinks Bush is complicit (false), while the text says Hoffman thinks Bush is a manipulator (true).
 
As I have often noted -loathe Bush, certain he did not cause 9/11.

Manipulating the situation presented after 9/11 like the cold-hearted slime he and his bbuddies are - no question at all that he did.
 
Lisa Simpson said:
From that quote, I don't think Dustin Hoffman is saying MIHOP. He's saying that post-9/11, Bush manipulated the grief of Americans to justify invading Iraq. Which he did and continues to do.
Click to expand...

And we are all aware and pissed about that.
 
At what point does he explain the pull it comment? I skimmed it and none of his interview clips mention the pull it comment, that I found.
 
Lisa Simpson said:
From that quote, I don't think Dustin Hoffman is saying MIHOP. He's saying that post-9/11, Bush manipulated the grief of Americans to justify invading Iraq. Which he did and continues to do.
Click to expand...


"Manipulated the grief" makes it sound like Bush picked up a hot chick at a funeral. I think "manipulated the fear" is probably a more accurate description.

-Gumboot
 
That's one where I'll give shrub the benefit of the doubt and give him at least three manipulates : fear, grief and hate.
 
All politicians are manipulators. AL Gore would have manipulated grief to get whatever he wanted.

That being said fear was being manipualted.
 
Why should anyone hang on a Hollywood actor's assessment of a political situation anyway? These are people paid to say words written for them by someone else.

I agree with the sentiment, but I don't see why it has more weight for coming coming from Dustin Hoffmann.
 
Big Al said:
Why should anyone hang on a Hollywood actor's assessment of a political situation anyway? These are people paid to say words written for them by someone else.

I agree with the sentiment, but I don't see why it has more weight for coming coming from Dustin Hoffmann.
Click to expand...

Not all of them. Some became famous improvising their own lines. They are more important because they are rich and famous. Yes Robin Leech makes them important.:rolleyes:
 
firecoins said:
Not all of them. Some became famous improvising their own lines. They are more important because they are rich and famous. Yes Robin Leech makes them important.:rolleyes:
Click to expand...

I stand corrected, firecoins! :o
 
I agree that Hoffman is not saying MIHOP, he's not even saying LIHOP. He's saying that the Bush administration took the shock of the 9/11 attacks to propel their plan to invade Iraq. The only thing even slightly controversial about that statement is whether the administration wanted to invade Iraq before 9/11 anyway. I think it's likely that they didn't, but when 9/11 happened they wanted to do something to smack the Arabs and look like a hero, so they naively figured they could sweep into Iraq, quickly oust Saddam, and then the Iraqis would throw a ticker-tape parade for their yankee liberators. I really think they thought this.

And why did that article describe Dustin Hoffman as "The RAIN MAN actor"? That seems kind of bizarre to me. Like describing Tom Hanks as the CAST AWAY actor. It kind of minimizes his long career.
 
CurtC said:
I agree that Hoffman is not saying MIHOP, he's not even saying LIHOP. He's saying that the Bush administration took the shock of the 9/11 attacks to propel their plan to invade Iraq. The only thing even slightly controversial about that statement is whether the administration wanted to invade Iraq before 9/11 anyway. I think it's likely that they didn't, but when 9/11 happened they wanted to do something to smack the Arabs and look like a hero, so they naively figured they could sweep into Iraq, quickly oust Saddam, and then the Iraqis would throw a ticker-tape parade for their yankee liberators. I really think they thought this.

.
Click to expand...
According to an interview on NPR a bit under two years ago with a gentleman(sorry, I don't know his name but given I was driving home mid-afternoon it was the Terry what's-her-name show but she was not on and interview was done by the guy who often subs for her) who had worked as an advisor with the Shrub people, they believed in that absolutely because of their intense belief in aspects of our government systems and their inablity to believe anyone would not jump at the chance to operate like us. He had tried and failed to convince them they were not totally correct.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom