• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Physiology 101

Just wanted to highlight this quote from Divina;

"It's hard to find good information in terms of anatomy/physiology, because so little is written about how body tissues function together or as a whole there."

Or could that be

Physiology: "The study of how living organisms function." (http://www.hyperdictionary.com/dictionary/physiology)

Damn. Those multi-volume physiology texts I read must have been a mirage, along with all their flow charts of interconnected physiological processes.

Just goes to show what happens when people with no medical training try to play at medicine.

She does offer an excellent (not) choice for an up to date review of reproductive physiology;

" However, you may find some good information to help you start piecing things together for yourself in Melissa Assilem's article on Folliculinum: Mist or Miasm. It is her write up of the remedy Folliculinum...and it includes a lot of information about how these tissues are connected and interdependent"
 
I think Kumar would be interested in this link. Judging by his posts (and the answers thereto) he is also a bit light on the physiology side.
 
BSM,

I've always been amused by your persecution of homoeopaths and have assumed that it's your way of winding down. Because I haven't spent enough time on homoeopathic boards, I haven't appreciated the tone of their posts.

Unless I'm very much mistaken this thread describes an 18 year old, in training taking responsibility for someone's health who has a lump on their breast.

Are they quite mad ?
 
I think the 18 years is the age of the patient rather than the therapist. But as the latter says she's a second year student she may not be much older.

They do love the disappearing breast lump. Since they don't know if it is a cyst or an abscess or what, of course when it disappears they have cured cancer!

The longer case that Hans Weitbrecht quoted was ripped to shreds by BSM in an earlier thread in the same forum. The evasion that started when he tried to get clarification of what was meant by "Tissue-sample came back positive in meantime" was astonishing. It became clear that there had never been any positive confirmation of malignancy, and in fact the treatment with antibiotics suggested that the lump was probably an abscess. Which of course would tend to resolve in the end no matter what. (I think that thread was another of the many victims of Stalin's airbrush, unfortunately.)

I love the way they all witter on about these indeterminate "connections", and show bugger-all knowledge of physiology, but when the argument gets heated, suddenly Divina knows all about oxytocin! Hey, Divina, did you forget you're not supposed to enquire what goes on inside the body, or why any of the symptoms you observe are occurring?

Don, now you realise. Both BSM and I are simply outraged that people are preying on the vulnerable with this delusional nonsense. We're particularly incensed that this nonsense is tacitly accepted within our own profession, and fellow-professionals promote it to their clients as being a valid branch of medicine. In order to be ready to argue against this, we find it useful to debate the issues here, and to debate with them on their own territory (until we get banned).

Rolfe.
 
Don

Just to enlarge on one aspect of what Rolfe said, I used to have a less irate attitude to them, but over time, every anecdote I have heard from them has involved either amazing stupidity on their parts or a wilful misreprestentaion of the facts of a case, all wrapped up in the ready-made excuses of homeopathy in which any outcome can be explained to 'prove' that the remedy has worked.

In our own profession we know of cases where great suffering has been caused. Obviously this is a small and biased sample, but it is not the result of disgruntled clients coming back to me and complaining, both the client and therapist have appeared happy with the progress, it's just that to an outsider the real facts are obvious.

http://www.randi.org/vbulletin/show...ghlight=acute+moist+dermatitis#post1870403655

I'm afrraid I can no longer view them as harmless eccentrics, they are untrained bus drivers who think that the pretty red, orange and amber lights are placed at junctions for decoration.
 

Back
Top Bottom