• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Iraqi minorities persecuted

Meadmaker

Unregistered
Joined
Apr 27, 2004
Messages
29,033
I had a disturbing conversation yesterday.

A recently hired coworker of mine is Chaldean. I had never heard of Chaldeans until I moved to Detroit, but there are a lot of them here. Chaldeans are an ethnic minority in Iraq. They are also found in Syria and Lebanon. Perhaps other places throughout the middle east. I don't really know. They speak a language fairly close to Hebrew or Aramaic. They are overwhelmingly Christians, members of the Chaldean Catholic Church.

They are closely related to Assyrians. My coworker described the difference between Assyrians and Chaldeans saying that the Assyrians had followed the Greek Orthodox path, while the Chaldeans were closer to the Roman Catholic path. Their languages were mutually comprehensible.

There is also a group of many thousand people called the Mandaeans, or I've seen it transliterated as Mendeyeen. This obscure group of people are actually spiritual descendants of John the Baptist, and are the closest representatives of the gnostics in our times.

None of these groups did well under Saddam. The reason there are so many Assyrians and Chaldeans in Detroit is that they came here fleeing persecution under Saddam. Now, though, things are even worse. Since the war, persecution has increased. Now, it seems, the Shiites, Sunnis, and Kurds you have heard so much about have launched a new wave of anti-minority violence. Angered by the words of the Pope, Iraqis have been attacking Chaldeans, Assyrians, and other Christians again. My coworker reported that his uncle, still in Iraq, was forced to flee Baghdad last week with his family. It seems that things are a little better in the north of Iraq, but he intends to move to Greece or America if he gets the chance.

We here so much about Sunnis, Shia, and Kurds that we forget that until recently, there were others in Iraq as well. The Jews have already been run out of Iraq, where there had been a significant Jewish presence since the time of Babylon. Literally a few dozen remain, according to a report I heard on the radio. My coworker predicts that in a few years, the Chaldeans, Assyrians, and Mandaeans will all be destoyed or exiled.

This story doesn't have much of a point. I won't say it's Bush's fault, or that only Bush can save them. It just seems like we know so little about these places that are so important to us. When hearing about what to do in Iraq, just remember that the people offering the "solutions" have probably never even heard of some of the people who are losing lives, homes, and ways of life.
 
I would be greatly surprised if the Kurds are practicing such persecution (granting the possibility or even likelihood of exceptions on the individual level).

I visited Kurdistan twice in 2003 and was amazed at the society they had managed to establish under the protection of the US and UN via the No-Fly Zones.

On their own, with no urging from anyone and no help except from UNICEF, they established their own governments (Kurdistand had two parts governed separately; they have since united) with various Ministries. My work was with the Ministries of Education. They had established a multi-religious, multi-lingual school system. It was not complete yet, but was well on the way. Children were taught in the language of their home, and religious studies included Islam, Christianity, Yazidi, Assyriac, Chaldean, and Judaism. Possibly others I am forgetting.

The Kurds are as prone to mis-rule and misbehavior as anyone else, but they demonstrated a remarkable capacity to overcome it.
 
I had a disturbing conversation yesterday.

A recently hired coworker of mine is Chaldean. I had never heard of Chaldeans until I moved to Detroit, but there are a lot of them here. Chaldeans are an ethnic minority in Iraq. They are also found in Syria and Lebanon. Perhaps other places throughout the middle east. I don't really know. They speak a language fairly close to Hebrew or Aramaic. They are overwhelmingly Christians, members of the Chaldean Catholic Church.

They are closely related to Assyrians. My coworker described the difference between Assyrians and Chaldeans saying that the Assyrians had followed the Greek Orthodox path, while the Chaldeans were closer to the Roman Catholic path. Their languages were mutually comprehensible.

There is also a group of many thousand people called the Mandaeans, or I've seen it transliterated as Mendeyeen. This obscure group of people are actually spiritual descendants of John the Baptist, and are the closest representatives of the gnostics in our times.

None of these groups did well under Saddam. The reason there are so many Assyrians and Chaldeans in Detroit is that they came here fleeing persecution under Saddam. Now, though, things are even worse. Since the war, persecution has increased. Now, it seems, the Shiites, Sunnis, and Kurds you have heard so much about have launched a new wave of anti-minority violence. Angered by the words of the Pope, Iraqis have been attacking Chaldeans, Assyrians, and other Christians again. My coworker reported that his uncle, still in Iraq, was forced to flee Baghdad last week with his family. It seems that things are a little better in the north of Iraq, but he intends to move to Greece or America if he gets the chance.

We here so much about Sunnis, Shia, and Kurds that we forget that until recently, there were others in Iraq as well. The Jews have already been run out of Iraq, where there had been a significant Jewish presence since the time of Babylon. Literally a few dozen remain, according to a report I heard on the radio. My coworker predicts that in a few years, the Chaldeans, Assyrians, and Mandaeans will all be destoyed or exiled.

This story doesn't have much of a point. I won't say it's Bush's fault, or that only Bush can save them. It just seems like we know so little about these places that are so important to us. When hearing about what to do in Iraq, just remember that the people offering the "solutions" have probably never even heard of some of the people who are losing lives, homes, and ways of life.
I think good hearted Americans should start a letter writing campaign to suggest to Congress that the US has a moral obligation to treat these people as a special case of refugees -- like the Viet Namese Boat People of the 1970's. Our immigration policy should be adjusted to allow as many who wish refuge in our country -- with of course security checks -- due to our policy having been a root cause of their current plight.

That strikes me as "doing what is right by people who you have unintentionally screwed over."

Who is with me?

If you like, I can draft this weekend a letter for you to send to Congressmen and Senators and offer it to the JREF community as a whole, for viral dissemination as appropriate. I'll post it here by Sunday night if there is sufficient support for the idea.

I await the JREF response.

DR
 
Palestinians Targeted With Death Threats

Here's another minority group that seems to be having lot's of fun in Iraq. This is reported today my Human Rights Watch.

Iraq: Palestinians Targeted With Death Threats
Human Rights Watch
New York, October 6, 2006
http://www.hrw.org/english/docs/2006/10/06/iraq14350.htm

Shi`a armed groups have threatened to kill Palestinian refugees living in Baghdad if they do not leave Iraq within 72 hours, Human Rights Watch said today.

Human Rights Watch urged the Iraqi government and the Multi-National Forces to investigate these threats and provide greater security to Palestinians in Iraq.

A new leaflet obtained by Human Rights Watch and bearing the name of the Al-Bayt Revenge Brigade – Rapid Response Units states that “there is no place for Palestinians in the Iraq of Ali, Hassan, and Hussain.” The names refer to three revered Shi`a imams; in contrast, virtually all Palestinians are Sunni Muslim. The leaflet also warns that “our swords can reach necks” and urges Palestinians to leave within 72 hours and “fight occupation in your own country,” referring to Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories.

Nowhere to Flee
The Perilous Situation of Palestinians in Iraq
Human Rights Watch
September 2006 Volume 18, No. 4(E)
http://hrw.org/reports/2006/iraq0706/

A Face and a Name
Civilian Victims of Insurgent Groups in Iraq
Human Rights Watch
October 2005 Vol. 17, No. 9(E)
http://hrw.org/reports/2005/iraq1005/
 
Last edited:
Here's another minority group that seems to be having lot's of fun in Iraq. This is reported today my Human Rights Watch.

Shi`a armed groups have threatened to kill Palestinian refugees living in Baghdad if they do not leave Iraq within 72 hours, Human Rights Watch said today.

Human Rights Watch urged the Iraqi government and the Multi-National Forces to investigate these threats and provide greater security to Palestinians in Iraq.

A new leaflet obtained by Human Rights Watch and bearing the name of the Al-Bayt Revenge Brigade – Rapid Response Units states that “there is no place for Palestinians in the Iraq of Ali, Hassan, and Hussain.” The names refer to three revered Shi`a imams; in contrast, virtually all Palestinians are Sunni Muslim. The leaflet also warns that “our swords can reach necks” and urges Palestinians to leave within 72 hours and “fight occupation in your own country,” referring to Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories.
Cutting the irony with a knife, I note that part of the Bush team's strategy was in enabling the "road map for peace" (Israel/Pal) with his invasion of Iraq to spread democracy. The Bush team then supported the Shia au outrance, with predictable results: a mobocracy.

Looks like the sheep (Palestinians) are being eyed by a few wolves in Iraqi clothing.

DR
 

Back
Top Bottom