• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Holistic Research in Canada

Jas

Illuminator
Joined
Jan 2, 2004
Messages
3,833
Link to article

Calgary to lead way for holistic research
New centre breaks ground in Canada

Mario Toneguzzi
Calgary Herald


Monday, February 07, 2005

Calgary is poised to become the national leader in research and training in the field of complementary and alternative medicine.

The city will be the site of Canada's first post-secondary institute dedicated to advancing complementary and alternative health, as well as the first place where information about scientifically proven alternative health options will be offered by the Calgary Health Region on its 24-hour phoneline.

The two initiatives will be announced at a news conference today at Mount Royal College, the Herald has learned.

Pat Trottier, Integrative Health Institute chairwoman at Mount Royal, said "there is a growing demand and need for quality, trustworthy evidence-based information around complementary and alternative health.

"That has grown out of the huge demand from the general public for it," said Trottier.

"We know from previous studies there are more visits to non-conventional healers than there are sometimes to MDs.

"As it has become more and more popular, traditional medicine has looked at it and said, 'What is there about this that we can integrate into our practices?' And they are slowly doing that, but it is all based around what has been scientifically proven to work."

Complementary and alternative health care describes a wide range of therapies and products that are not part of conventional medicine as practised by mainstream doctors.

They share the common characteristic of working in conjunction with the body's self-healing mechanisms, are holistic in treating the whole person, involve the patient as an active participant and focus on disease prevention and well-being.

Therapies include everything from acupuncture to energy healing, yoga and aromatherapy.

Dr. Badri Rickhi, executive director of the Canadian Institute of Natural and Integrative Medicine, said today's announcement is very important because "there are little pieces scattered all around the place we've been trying to connect and work together."

"One of the areas is in education -- doing research in education and teaching people to become researchers," said Rickhi, a clinical associate professor with the University of Calgary's faculty of medicine and vice-president of the Canadian Medical Acupuncture Society.

"Sixty per cent of people in Alberta at one time will use integrative medicine. So getting us all connected to serving them is extremely important

. . . People are looking at options for wellness and prevention and people are just curious on how they can better their health. We're becoming more concerned about our health than we have ever been before. In Alberta, particularly Calgary, we're extremely health conscious. It's one of the most health-conscious cities in Canada.

National polls done in 2000 estimated between 60 per cent and 70 per cent of Canadians sought some type of complementary or alternative health care in the previous year. In a 1999 Canadian survey, conducted on behalf of the Fraser Institute, 73 per cent reported using complementary or alternative health care sometime in their life.
The Fraser Institute survey suggests the Canadian population spent more than $1.8 billion out-of-pocket on visits to providers of alternative medicine in 1997. Additional spending on books, medical equipment, herbs, vitamins and special diet programs pushed that figure to more than $3.8 billion.

Dr. Marja Verhoef, head of the Canada Research Chair in Complementary Medicine at the U of C's faculty of medicine, said it's important to know more about the field because "people are using it a lot."

"People don't always know how effective and how safe they are, and people may not always know how to make decisions about them," said Verhoef. "Those things need to be addressed. People need to be educated about it. They need to be studied. And there needs to be information about it.

"We do need to look at how this can play a role in the health-care system . . . I think the initiative at Mount Royal College is a good beginning, but a lot more needs to happen."

mtoneguzzi@theherald.canwest.com

© The Calgary Herald 2005

Sorry about the entire article, they generally don't archive them though.

What 'scientifically proven alternative therapies' are there? I think a letter to the editor is in order, and I cannot believe that there isn't more outcry over this.
 
I've done a quick medline search of Dr. Verhoef's publications (A CRC chair is extremely prestigious and usually reserved for leaders or potential leaders in the field. There are problems with the program but that is for another thread).

Here are some examples of the research supporting CAM, note esp. the idea of developing unique approaches to assessing the efficacy of CAM:

Mulkins A. Verhoef M. Eng J. Findlay B. Ramsum D.

Title
Evaluation of the Tzu Chi Institute for Complementary and Alternative Medicine's Integrative Care Program.

Source
Journal of Alternative & Complementary Medicine. 9(4):585-92, 2003 Aug.

Abstract
OBJECTIVE: There are an increasing number of clinics providing integrative health care using new and innovative delivery models. The purpose of this study was to quantitatively and qualitatively evaluate the Integrative Care Program offered at the Tzu Chi Institute for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. DESIGN: At enrollment, data are collected on demographics, health history, current health concerns and diagnoses, quality of life/health status (SF-36) and patient satisfaction. The measures are repeated 6 months into the program. Descriptive analysis was used to summarize the data. Focus groups were also included as part of the study design. RESULTS: Patients seeking integrative care are a highly complex population living with numerous comorbid chronic conditions. Although their baseline scores on the SF-36 are lower than Canadian population norms across all subscales, significant improvement occurred from baseline to 6 months. Qualitative data support that patients were pleased with the clinical care they received and aligned with the philosophical underpinnings of the program. DISCUSSION: This is one of the first studies to evaluate integrative health care. Studies like this are needed to develop appropriate methods to assess models of integrative health care delivery.

Ritenbaugh C. Verhoef M. Fleishman S. Boon H. Leis A.
Title
Whole systems research: a discipline for studying complementary and alternative medicine. [Review] [23 refs]

Source
Alternative Therapies in Health & Medicine. 9(4):32-6, 2003 Jul-Aug.

Abstract
The new discipline of whole systems research (WSR) targets the study of complex CAM therapies as system-level phenomena, as opposed to single-agent or uni-dimensional effects. This article describes the pre-defined goals, issues that were developed, and opportunities that were revealed in a workshop held in Vancouver BC, in which scientists, practitioners, and policy makers met to lay the foundations of WSR. Important issues were identified, such as treatment individualization, problems of diagnosis, patient-practitioner interaction, varying therapeutic contexts, and patient-determined outcome values. Research design issues that were addressed included a variety of challenges to the study of intact systems, in relation to both synergy and emergent behaviors, and the opportunities to innovate the conventional RCT. As the network of CAM scientists and practitioners engaged in WSR expands, a common nomenclature and body of techniques will help us to a better understanding of the ways in which whole systems affect healing. [References: 23]
 
I couldn't find anything from the Chair, P. Trottier.

But this research is by Dr. Rickhi:

Rickhi B. Quan H. Moritz S. Stuart HL. Arboleda-Florez J.

Title
Mental disorders and reasons for using complementary therapy.

Source
Canadian Journal of Psychiatry - Revue Canadienne de Psychiatrie. 48(7):475-9, 2003 Aug.

Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To compare patients with and without mental disorders who seek services from a complementary therapy practitioner with regard to quality of life, reasons for seeking complementary therapies, complaints, and physical conditions. METHOD: We studied new patients who attended a complementary therapy clinic offering acupuncture treatment between July 1, 1993, and March 31, 1995. We collected data from a self-administered questionnaire and from a physician-conducted psychiatric assessment. RESULTS: Of the 826 new patients at the clinic, 578 (70%) presented with a mental disorder. Patients with a mental disorder perceived their quality of life as poorer and reported greater levels of stress than did those without a mental disorder. However, the groups did not differ in their self-reported reasons for seeking complementary therapies, in their complaints, or in their physical conditions. Among patients with a mental disorder, the major reasons for choosing complementary therapies were personal preference, interest, or belief in complementary therapies (44.3%) and perceiving complementary therapies as a last resort (30.7%). Most patients with a mental disorder saw a complementary practitioner for musculoskeletal and connective-tissue disorders (44.1%), fatigue (26.6%), and headache (15.2%). The most frequent physical illnesses among patients with a mental disorder were diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue (42.6%). CONCLUSION: Like their counterparts without a mental disorder, individuals with a mental disorder use complementary therapies because of personal beliefs. The wide use of complementary therapies among individuals with a mental disorder may be ascribed to a poor quality of life and high levels of distress.
 
Calgary? Noooooo!!!!:eek:
where information about scientifically proven alternative health options will be offered by the Calgary Health Region on its 24-hour phoneline.

WTH?

What "scientifically proven alternative health options"

Where are they building this specious clap trap?
a clinical associate professor with the University of Calgary's faculty of medicine and vice-president of the Canadian Medical Acupuncture Society...
Dr. Marja Verhoef, head of the Canada Research Chair in Complementary Medicine at the U of C's faculty of medicine

Okay, now I see our system is more eroded than I figured. No wonder my tubal didn't work... (yeah yeah, just making fun here :p )

The U of C is a fricken joke!
 
And here I thought Calgary was doing well when January's "letter of the month" in the Herald was written by a sleptic and challenging psychics. They even showed a pic of the author holding a photo of Randi when they reprinted it. Sadly, I cannot remember who wrote it.

So I think more letters regarding this article are in order.
 
If they'll bother with us. They'll be oh so busy with all their "important" work to spread manure around Calgary.
 
Altmed

One plus one equals two. But I'm open to the idea that it might also equal three. And it would please me if that possibility were integrated into arithmetic class. And my quality of life would improve if people would be respectful of my beliefs, and support the thought that one plus one might equal all sorts of things. And more research will be needed on this topic, as a variety of sums become more widely accepted and popular.
 
:D You're funny nicholls

I just got a reply elswhere using the appeal to authority on how "educated" these people are. OH, and how we shouldn't turn our backs on it even though we cannot prove any of it works NOW.

My tax dollars are being wasted because of this bleeding heart logic?

Ugh.
 
Re: Altmed

nicholls said:
One plus one equals two. But I'm open to the idea that it might also equal three.

Well, you can actually prove that 1+1=2, but, as one of my math prof put it, "it's a real pain" ;).
 
Yeah, U of C is pretty sketchy...especially their med school. I have friends who go there, one of which thinks that chiropractors are good for 'maintenance', and sees them on a regular basis.
 

Back
Top Bottom