Badlyshavedmonkey equation is dissproved!

[Dr. A Sheikh]

Badlyshavedmonkey at this forum derived an equation to explain the effect of Avogadro's Number on homeopathic dilutions. On that equation Dr. MAS offered million dollar ruppees with the help of many homeopathic pharmacies in Pakistan and said, if anybody who will prove BSM equation, he will give million ruppees. the equation should be endorsed with two Ph.D doctors.

Now at NCH forum a member named "highdesert" clarified that

Dr. MAS, when Badly Shaved Monkey's equation was rejected at the first step, it was because he made a small mistake. He fixed it. It did not change the result.

http://www.nch.ipbfree.com/index.php?showtopic=474&st=30

This proves that Dr. MAS was right. At this stage even then, BSM or anyother feels that he wants to win the prize then the offers still stands.

Visit http://www.nchpakistan.com site and read the offer.

 

[Mojo]

Do you have any evidence to support the assertion in your sig yet?

Just asking.

 

[Mojo]

This proves that Dr. MAS was right.

Wrong!

1. BSM's calculations have not been "disproved". There was merely a mistake in the first version, which was subsequently corrected, as pointed out in the very post you're quoting!

2. Even if the result of BSM's calculations were proven to be wrong, this would not prove that MAS is right. That is a false dilemma.

 

[Dr. A Sheikh]

Actually the derived equation was divided into many steps. The first step was absoultly wrong and Dr. MAS pointed out and said, if you insist the step is correct then I will offer you million ruppees. BSM is now corrected the equation and informed the NCH members through highdesert (a possible alias).

You are a sensible person, how can an equation could be derived correctly if you commit a mistake in calculation in the very first step. On the basis of that mistake a correct equation cannot give you same answer.

 

[Z]

Have you worked out the remaining equation from that corrected step?

 

[Dr. A Sheikh]

yes, that is wrong!

 

[Mojo]

You are a sensible person, how can an equation could be derived correctly if you commit a mistake in calculation in the very first step. On the basis of that mistake a correct equation cannot give you same answer.

Read the post you quoted:

He fixed it.

Do you understand? The error was corrected.

Now that we've disposed of that, are you going to provide some evidence to back up the claim in your signature, or are you going to admit that it isn't true?

 

[The Central Scrutinizer]

Badlyshavedmonkey at this forum derived an equation to explain the effect of Avogadro's Number on homeopathic dilutions. On that equation Dr. MAS offered million dollar ruppees with the help of many homeopathic pharmacies in Pakistan and said, if anybody who will prove BSM equation, he will give million ruppees. the equation should be endorsed with two Ph.D doctors.

This proves that Dr. MAS was right. At this stage even then, BSM or anyother feels that he wants to win the prize then the offers still stands.

Dr. A,

Could you increase the prize money? You see, 1,000,000 Rupees is only worth about 38 cents in the US.

Thank you for your consideration in this matter.

 

[Z]

yes, that is wrong!

Seems not everyone agrees with you. How about you post what you worked out, right here, so we can all see how the correction by BSM in fact altered the rest of the equation.

 

[Dr. A Sheikh]

Who pointed out the error?

 

[Z]

Who pointed out the error?

Quit changing the subject. Just post your work, demonstrating the variance from BSM's corrected work, and this discussion can continue.

 

[ungoliant]

and please provide evidence proving your signature.

 

[Z]

Oh, and while we're making impossible demands, go ahead and post the credentials allowing you to call yourself a doctor. Thanks!

 

[Dr. A Sheikh]

again! who put the equation correct?

 

[Garrette]

Apparently, Badly Shaved Monkey did, as soon as he was made aware of the error.

This is in marked contrast to you and to other homeopaths who obfuscate and ignore when errors are pointed out.

Kudos to BSM.

 

[Hitch]

Dr. A,

Could you increase the prize money? You see, 1,000,000 Rupees is only worth about 38 cents in the US.

Thank you for your consideration in this matter.

About $22,700 at the moment. (Just sayin')

Hey, Central Scrutinizer, can I borrow 38 cents?

 

[ungoliant]

Oh, and while we're making impossible demands, go ahead and post the credentials allowing you to call yourself a doctor. Thanks!

well, i am royal doctor to the emporer norton 1st.

and who put the equation correct? purple vomit dishwasher! testing....testing...onetwothreefourfivetwelve....testing.....testes....

 

[Dr. A Sheikh]

Apparently, Badly Shaved Monkey did, as soon as he was made aware of the error.

This is in marked contrast to you and to other homeopaths who obfuscate and ignore when errors are pointed out.

Kudos to BSM.

You did not participate in the discussion, you are not aware of anything.

 

[Dr Adequate]

Well done! "Dr" Sheik. Let me in return point out some of your mistakes:

(1) The trash in your signature appears to be the delusional ravings of a halfwit, a lunatic, or a particularly clumsy liar.
(2) You claim to be a "Dr" when you have no such qualification.
(3) You think that people can be healed using stupid magic water.

 

[Garrette]

You did not participate in the discussion, you are not aware of anything.

My deepest apologies for assuming I could take meaning from what you yourself posted.

I will not make that mistake again, I assure you.